A “Very Honest” Tory Leader
Location
View Larger Map
Other maps: Bing, Google, MapQuest.
Coordinates: 35.971, -80.4047.
Tour: Hidden
County: Davie
None
The coordinates take you to Underpass Road near Bermuda Run, and are as close as you can get to the likely homesite of Samuel Bryan.1 However, parking is not allowed along this section of the road. The former Bryan land remains private property, and the exact sites of his home and mill are unknown.
Description
Colonizing the Forks
The biggest name in this region prior to the American Revolution was Bryan, though it was often written “Bryant,” even in official records. Danish-born2 Morgan and Martha Bryan first moved their large family from Pennsylvania to Virginia, when their son Samuel was at least four.3 He was around 22 when they continued to “the Forks of the Yadkin,” between the Yadkin and South Yadkin rivers. The clan crossed at the Shallow Ford 11 miles upriver in 1748, and began buying large swaths of land from the ford southward.
Samuel Bryan joined the colony’s part-time militia in 1754 as the French & Indian War broke out. He helped protect European-Americans in the region from Native American allies of the French, mainly the Cherokees. Bryan families “forted up” for protection at times at Bethabara in today’s Winston-Salem or Fort Dobbs near modern Statesville.
With help from his father, Samuel built up wealth through land sales. He bought 2,000 acres most sources place at the coordinates. There he farmed, owned a grain mill, and had a fishing operation using nets in the river and several creeks. He apparently also had a ferry crossing the river, and was licensed to run an “ordinary,” a tavern travelers could stay in overnight.
This area was part of Rowan County at the time. Bryan held positions of importance such as justice of the peace, which included the duties of a modern county commissioner and judge. Local members of the official Church of England proposed him to the colonial government for membership on a church council (“vestry”) for a new parish of the official Anglican Church.4
Samuel’s niece Rebecca married frontiersman Daniel Boone, who would go on to fame for his role in creating the state of Kentucky. One source says Bryan and Boone were appointed to mark the route for the road from Shallow Ford to Salisbury in 1763.5
Along with Boone, Bryan apparently stayed out of the Regulator protests against the colonial government in the late 1760s. Of course, Samuel was part of that government, but there’s no evidence he joined the colonial troops who marched against the Regulators, either.
Loyalist Leanings Lead to Action
Like many in the Forks, Samuel pushed back as revolution spread across the English colonies, though three of his brothers joined the rebels. A captain in the militia, he called for his company to muster one day early in the war, probably 1775, according to one of his men, Richard Pearson. Pearson asked some of the men to load their guns before Bryan arrived. Bryan ordered the soldiers into formation and Pearson refused, apparently believing Bryan expected them to support the British. Bryan tried to have him arrested, and Pearson resisted, informing Bryan he had supporters ready to shoot. Pearson claimed someone in the company then suggested a fist-fight to determine which direction the company would take! The men agreed, Pearson won, and the company went Whig (or “Patriot”), he said. Presumably the Loyalists or “Tories” among them went off with Bryan.5
Bryan was hauled before the Committee of Safety of Rowan County, the Patriot replacement for the collapsed colonial government, in August 1775. This was probably due to his signing, and perhaps writing, a petition (or “association”) of support for Royal Gov. Josiah Martin. Another 193 men from Rowan and Surry counties did as well. They were responding to petitions from Patriots protesting royal actions. After pledging allegiance to British law, this Tory one said in part: “we utterly protest against meetings of people against the peace thereof or anything which may give birth to sedition and insurrection. We cannot but express to your Excellency that we consider all such Associations at this Crisis of very dangerous fatality to your Excellency’s good Government of this Province… (and) we are determined with the assistance of God in our respective stations steadfastly to continue (being) his Majesty’s loyal subjects…”
In January 1776, Martin called for volunteers to help British armies on their way to regain control of the colony.7 Bryan recruited some men and guided them to the Loyalist disaster at the Battle of Moore’s Creek Bridge. Bryan somehow evaded capture, unlike most of the Tories. He laid low for a year and a half, claiming later to be “‘the only British officer to escape,’”8 though he was wrong.
He made his way to New York City the next year, occupied by the British army. Bryan met with Martin and other British leaders to reassure them of continued Loyalist support in North Carolina. When he tried to return, he was blocked by Whig militia in Virginia and retreated to Philadelphia, recently captured by the British. Hence the optimistic tone of a letter to his wife intercepted by Patriots, which claimed “‘the Inglish (sic) is taking every place that they attempt at…’”
He was indicted for treason under the new state’s laws in Salisbury, the court declaring him “‘a person of evil name and fame…’” When and how he got back to the Forks is unknown. But after the British reclaimed South Carolina, Bryan raised 700–800 Tory troops in June 1780, against the wishes of British commander Lt. Gen. Lord Charles Cornwallis. Expecting to move north at some point, Cornwallis likely wanted them to remain on their farms to provide food for his army.
As Cornwallis explained to the British commander-in-chief in New York, “Col. Bryan, altho’ he had promised to wait for my orders, lost all patience, and rose with about 800 Men on the Yadkin, and by a difficult and dangerous March joined Major M’Arthur on the borders of Anson County.” Cornwallis said only about two-thirds were armed. He partially excused Bryan by noting that the state government was “making great Exertions to raise Troops, and persecuting our friends in the most cruel manner…”9
The regional state militia commander, Brig. Gen. Griffith Rutherford, learned of Bryan’s march and led troops to block him. An advance unit caught Bryan and defeated him at the Battle of Colson’s Mill. But Bryan and most of the men escaped, taking with them Patriots they had captured along the way. These he turned over to McArthur, who with 25 cavalry dragoons had occupied the Anson County Courthouse. They then continued toward the main British camp in South Carolina.
A year later the British and their Tory allies were divided into garrisons across S.C., and Whig militia embarked on a campaign against them. Bryan’s remaining 500 Loyalists were on Hanging Rock Creek, southeast of Lancaster, with other forces nearby. As a diversion for an attack on the latter, less than 100 Patriots under Maj. William Davie snuck into Bryan’s camp, surrounded the Tories there, and routed them.10
Sources differ on whether Bryan’s men were in the reserve at the Battle of Camden (S.C.), a major victory for Cornwallis over regular Continental troops, or Bryan commanded part of a regiment of N.C. Loyalists.11 Equally unclear is what Bryan did during Cornwallis’ last invasion of North Carolina, from the “Race to the Dan” through the British departure to Virginia. One source says his unit was put in charge of the British battalion horses.12 He is not mentioned by the Moravians, who knew the Bryans well, in their records of the British passage through their area. If he was on the campaign, like other Tory militia his unit would have missed the Battle of Guilford Court House while guarding supplies and camp followers at Bell’s Mill.13 Perhaps, though, he was among those left behind to try to hold South Carolina.
A Long Loop Home
Regardless, at some point Bryan and two of his officers were captured by Patriots. In Spring 1782, with the war winding down, they were tried for treason. Among their defense lawyers were Richard Henderson, Daniel Boone’s employer in Kentucky, and William Davie, the victor at Hanging Rock! The trio was convicted and condemned to hang. However, a report sent to the governor stated, “they were generally considered as very honest men, nor did it appear to the Court that they had on their march… committed any violences more than any other Army would have done in similar circumstances, in supplying themselves with Arms, ammunitions, provisions, horses, &c., there being no proof of their having been guilty of any murders, house-burning or plundering…”14 The sentence was delayed long enough for his lawyers to petition the state for clemency, which was granted. The Continental Army agreed to arrange an exchange for three Whigs, and Bryan and his colleagues were sent to the British in Charleston.
The state had confiscated the lands of Loyalists, but apparently it did not sell off the Bryans’ land. After his conviction, the court noted the needs of his wife Elisabeth and their eight daughters still at home, one an infant. Elisabeth was allowed to keep 900 acres, as well as people they held in slavery.
Bryan received pay from the British for his service through July 1782, when his unit was officially disbanded.15 He was shipped with other Tories to St. Augustine in Florida, still a British colony. But a year later Florida reverted to Spanish ownership as part of the treaty ending the Revolution. (Like France, Spain was a Patriot ally.) Most Tories moved to Canada, but Bryan took a ship to Wilmington. Detained briefly, he then returned home.
Apparently Bryan was allowed to resume his pre-war life. His mill was probably on the creek at the coordinates above, but closer to the river. If you drive past them, you will be on land owned by Bryan, whose home was probably near where the power transmission lines nearby cross the Yadkin a short distance to the east.
At some point Bryan traveled to Kentucky to visit relatives, who had moved there with Daniel Boone. Bryan died around age 73. He and his wife are believed to be buried either somewhere on their farm or in the Bryan family cemetery, now lost on the grounds of Oak Valley Golf Community.16
More Information
- Bryan, John, ‘Bryan, Samuel’, NCpedia <https://www.ncpedia.org/biography/bryan-samuel> [accessed 27 April 2024]
- Bryan, Samuel, ‘Address of Inhabitants of Rowan and Surry Counties to Josiah Martin Concerning Loyalty to Great Britain, Volume 09, Page 1160’, Colonial and State Records of North Carolina <https://docsouth.unc.edu/csr/index.php/document/csr09-0372> [accessed 26 April 2024]
- Burke, Thomas, ‘Instructions to the Rowan County Sheriffs Concerning a Reprieve for Samuel Bryant, John Hampton, and Nicholas White, Volume 16, Page 270’, Documenting the American South: Colonial and State Records of North Carolina, 1782 <https://docsouth.unc.edu/csr/index.php/document/csr16-0084> [accessed 3 May 2024]
- Burke, Thomas, ‘Letter from Thomas Burke to Joel Lewis Burke, Volume 16, Page 269’, Documenting the American South: Colonial and State Records of North Carolina, 1782 <https://docsouth.unc.edu/csr/index.php/document/csr16-0083> [accessed 22 April 2022]
- Clark, Murtie June, Loyalists in the Southern Campaign of the Revolutionary War, Vol. I (Genealogical Publishing Co., Inc., 1981)
- Cornwallis, Earl Charles, ‘Letter from Charles Cornwallis, Earl Cornwallis to Henry Clinton [Extract], Volume 14, Pages 867-868’, Documenting the American South: Colonial and State Records of North Carolina, 1780 <https://docsouth.unc.edu/csr/index.php/document/csr14-0832> [accessed 26 April 2024]
- Dorney, Douglas R. and Jr., ‘The Odyssey of Loyalist Colonel Samuel Bryan’, Journal of the American Revolution, 2021 <https://allthingsliberty.com/2021/07/the-odyssey-of-loyalist-colonel-samuel-bryan/> [accessed 16 May 2022]
- DeMond, Robert, The Loyalists in North Carolina During the Revolution (Duke University Press, 1940)
- Hughes, Fred, ‘Davie County (The Forks of the Yadkin), North Carolina, Historical Documentation’ (Custom House, 1977)
- Kamper, Ken, ‘Daniel Boone and His Family in North Carolina—1749-1773’, 2017
- Martin, Josiah, ‘Commission to Appoint Allan Macdonald Et Al. as Officers of Loyalist Militias, Volume 10, Pages 441-443’, Documenting the American South: Colonial and State Records of North Carolina, 1776 <https://docsouth.unc.edu/csr/index.php/document/csr10-0218> [accessed 3 May 2024]
- Minutes of the North Carolina Senate, Volume 19, Pages 1-128’, Documenting the American South: Colonial and State Records of North Carolina, 1782 <https://docsouth.unc.edu/csr/index.html/document/csr19-0001#p19-98> [accessed 27 April 2024]
- Morgan Bryan, Family Group Sheet’, State Library of North Carolina, Geneaology and History Library, Vertical Files, ‘Bryant Family’
- Petition from Inhabitants of Rowan County Concerning the Vestry of St. Luke’s Parish, Volume 08, Pages 154-155’, Documenting the American South: Colonial and State Records of North Carolina, 1769 <https://docsouth.unc.edu/csr/index.php/document/csr08-0079> [accessed 3 May 2024]
- Phillips, Marcia D., Historic Shallow Ford in Yadkin Valley: Crossroads Between East and West (The History Press, 2022)
- Raynor, George, Patriots and Tories in Piedmont Carolina (Salisbury Printing Co. Inc., 1990)
- Sabine, Lorenzo, Biographical Sketches of Loyalists of the American Revolution: With an Historical Essay (Boston : Little, Brown and Company, 1864), I <http://archive.org/details/biosketchloyal01sabirich> [accessed 18 May 2022]
- Samuel “Colonel” Bryan (1726-1799)’, Find a Grave Memorial <https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/257773303/samuel-bryan> [accessed 27 April 2024]
- Sherman, Wm. Thomas, Calendar and Record of the Revolutionary War in the South: 1780-1781, Tenth Edition (Gun Jones Publishing, 2007)
- Smart, J. Saumel, ‘Morgan Bryan I’, Genealogical Society of Central Missouri, 25.3 (2006)
- Sherman, Wm. Thomas, ‘Morgan Bryan II’, Genealogical Society of Central Missouri, 25.4 (2006)
- Spencer, Samuel, and John Williams, ‘Orders from Thomas Burke, Volume 16, Pages 263-269’, Documenting the American South: Colonial and State Records of North Carolina, 1782 <https://docsouth.unc.edu/csr/index.php/document/csr16-0082> [accessed 22 April 2022]
- Troxler, Carole Watterson, The Loyalist Experience in North Carolina (North Carolina Department of Cultural Resources, Division of Archives and History, 1976)
- Wall, Nancy, ‘Historic Davie County in the Forks of the Yadkin’, 1969, Martin-Wall Local History Room, Davie County Public Library
1 Wall 1969; Hughes 1977. One 1884 source stated a home of Bryan was still standing in Farmington, roughly six miles west of here, perhaps an earlier house (A.A. Harbin, quoted in Kamper 2017).
2 Group Sheet.
3 Smart a (MBI). A genealogical article says Samuel’s birth year is unclear, but 1722 at latest.
4 “Minutes of the North Carolina Senate.”
5 Smart b (MBII).
6 Wall. Pearson fought as a Patriot and told this story later in life as a judge. Pearson placed this as happening after the Declaration of Independence, but as you’ll read, that cannot be true.
7 “Minutes of the North Carolina Senate.”
8 Hughes.
9 Cornwallis 1780.
10 Demond.
11 NCpedia.
12 Hughes.
13 Hughes.
14 “Order from Thomas Burke” 1780.
15 Clark.
16 Find a Grave.